Mind Body Behavior LogoMind Body Behavior
    Professional Expansion

    Content Ideas for Coaches: Turn Everyday Moments Into Posts

    BY SARAH BURBY•November 20, 2026•9 min read
    Content Ideas for Coaches: Turn Everyday Moments Into Posts
    The best content ideas for coaches come from your own week: something you overheard at the grocery store, a moment you fell apart, or a question a client asked. Share what happened, give your take on it, and connect it to the change you help people make. Relatable stories build more trust than polished expertise.

    On one of our Beyond Billable Hours cohort calls this month, one of the coaches told me she'd been struggling with content because she thought every story had to be some big moment from years ago. She had way more recent stuff, she just didn't think it counted.

    It counts. A story could be something that happened last week at the grocery store, like hearing a parent say she's so excited Cheez-Its are on sale because that's the healthiest thing her kid will eat. You relay what you heard, you share why it worries you as a coach, and you tell people what you'd do instead, and that's a post.

    You are living your content every single day, and most of you are walking right past it.

    Your Best Content Is Already Happening to You

    One of our coaches works with picky eaters, and on that same call she came up with a story on the spot. She'd been at a friend's joint birthday party for their two kids, ages 2 and 4, in a backyard that looked like a farm. Her friend's husband raises his own pigs, keeps chickens and grows a huge garden. She said something like "how lucky is your son to grow up learning where his food comes from," and he told her the kid doesn't eat any of it, he only eats dino nuggets.

    That's a missed opportunity she could talk about for weeks, and it came from a birthday party. She'd never have thought of it as content if we hadn't been talking about it.

    Your audience wants this kind of thing. The 2025 Sprout Social Index found that authenticity and relatability are the two traits consumers value most from brands, and about half said original content is what makes their favorite brands stand out. Nobody else has your Saturday, so nobody else can post it.

    Why Relatable Wins Over Polished

    We have to get out of expert authority culture, because it's so 2024 and it isn't hitting anymore. People have information overwhelm. They'd rather connect with a person and what she's going through and say "same."

    The data backs that up. In Sprout Social's Q2 2026 Pulse Survey, 57% of consumers said they trust everyday users for product recommendations, compared with 26% who trust subject matter experts.

    I learned this one the funny way. At a retreat this fall I told a friend this was the hardest year of my life in business, and she was shocked. She said she'd never have guessed I struggle, which surprised me, because I try so hard to find the balance on my page. Apparently I need to talk about my struggles more.

    The same thing happened with a podcast episode I recorded with a PhD behavior analyst. She talked about still having imposter syndrome, and it became one of the most downloaded episodes I've ever put out, because people assume someone with a doctorate has it together all the time. Hearing her say otherwise made her more trustworthy to listeners. If you're working through imposter feelings in something new, you're not alone in that.

    Your audience is looking for a real person a few steps ahead who's willing to show them the path, and the stories you skip are how they find you.

    "But I'm Supposed to Have the Answers"

    One of our coaches laughed and told us she'd cried the night before because her delivery order was late and she wasn't going to get to bed on time. Then she got quiet and asked the question so many of you are thinking: she coaches people through overwhelm and overachieving, so if they know she still breaks down, is that okay?

    Yes, and that's literally a post. "Last Monday I cried because my delivery order was late" is silly and funny, and people can laugh with you. You can say you know it was kind of silly, those feelings still come up for you, and you were able to move on with your day. That last part is the coaching.

    There's research behind why this works. In the original study on the pratfall effect, Aronson, Willerman and Floyd (1966) found that a highly competent person who made a clumsy blunder became more likable, while the same blunder made an average person less likable. Your competence is what lets the mess make you human.

    I had my own crash-out at a conference this year. I texted Kendra, my business partner, and asked her to announce the next person because I was not okay and had tears in my eyes. I posted a picture of me crying on my stories, and to me that's a flex. A business coach who says she's perfect and never struggles is a big X for me, because I know she's lying about something.

    There is a balance. If every day I posted that my business was probably going to crash tomorrow, you'd wonder what you signed up for. I'm five steps ahead of you guys and I still struggle with different things, because I'm a human being. Stepping into the business owner mindset means letting people see the real version of the founder.

    When Your Hardest Season Is Behind You

    Another coach in our cohort supports women through infertility, a season she went through herself and is past now. She worried she didn't have active stories to share anymore.

    She has more than she thinks. She told us that even now, a pregnancy announcement can still catch her and she'll think about how much it would have hurt back then. Big gender reveals, the bad advice people give ("at least you know you can get pregnant"), the things her clients hear every week, all of that is content.

    She can also address the elephant in the room. She has two children now, and some of her audience may feel like it was easier for her. Saying that out loud, something like "I want you to know I have two kids, and I was in it with you," makes her human again, and she gets to choose the delicate way to say it.

    Your story doesn't have to be your direct experience either. Things you notice, things clients tell you and things you see online all count.

    How to Turn a Moment Into a Post

    Every one of these stories follows the same shape. You share what happened, you give your take as a coach, and you tell people what you'd do or what you want them to know. Here's how that looks with the moments from our call:

    Everyday momentYour take as a coachWhat the post does
    A parent cheering that Cheez-Its are on sale because it's the healthest thing her kid eatsPackaged snacks get treated as health food when kids won't eat anything elseGives parents one small swap to try this week
    A 4-year-old with a backyard farm who only eats dino nuggetsAccess to good food doesn't mean a kid will eat itShows how exposure and modeling at home make a difference
    Crying because a delivery order was lateOverwhelm still shows up for people who coach overwhelmModels naming the feeling and moving on with your day
    A pregnancy announcement that still stings years laterTriggers can outlast the season itselfTells followers their reaction is normal
    A friend saying she'd never guess you strugglePolished pages hide the hard parts of building a businessOpens the door to sharing one real struggle and what you did next

    Your homework from that call applies to you too. Take one idea and post it in two forms, like a carousel and a reel, with only a slight change between them. You'll learn which format your people gravitate toward and which gets more engagement, and you'll get two posts out of one moment.

    When you start talking about your offer in those posts, the same rule applies. You can market your coaching without feeling salesy when the story does most of the work.

    Getting Started This Week

    Your brain is going to start coming up with these stories tonight, so be ready to catch them.

    1. Start a running list. Keep a note on your phone and add anything you see, hear or remember that connects to your clients, even if it feels too small.
    2. Write one post from it. Share what happened, give your take, and close with what you'd do or what you want your reader to know.
    3. Post it twice. Make a carousel and a reel on the same idea and compare how people respond.
    4. Keep telling people what you do. Content works best alongside reaching out directly and telling people about your offer and your service.

    Some weeks it will feel like nobody is watching. That's normal, and we wrote about how to stay consistent in business when it feels like crickets.

    Build Your Content Habit Inside Beyond Billable Hours

    This is the kind of thing we work on live every week, with real coaches building real businesses and sharing the moments they almost didn't post. If you want people around you who'll tell you "that's literally a post," come build your coaching business with us in Beyond Billable Hours.

    I'd love to hear from you. Tell me the moment from this week you're turning into a post.

    Chat soon! ✨ Sarah

    Sarah Burby

    Sarah Burby

    Founder of Mind Body Behavior and Clinicians for MORE

    Mission: Mind Body Behavior exists to provide professional education and coaching for behavior analysts and health practitioners, elevating the standard of care through behavior change science.

    Stay in the Loop

    BACB ACE Provider OP-25-11663

    NBHWC-Approved Training Program

    © 2026 Mind Body Behavior LLC

    Become a Behavior Health Coach
    Joy
    Hi there! Have a question? Chat with us here.