How to Stay Consistent in Business When It's Crickets

To stay consistent in business when nothing seems to be working, count the small wins instead of only clients: new followers, link clicks, email signups and booked conversations. The early months of building a business can feel quiet, but that doesn't mean nothing is working. Choose a posting rhythm you can maintain, track the small wins along the way, and use what you're learning to make adjustments as you grow.
I'm building Beyond Billable Hours from scratch right now. Yes, I have the experience of building Mind Body Behavior, but this is a brand-new business, so I'm doing this right alongside the coaches in our cohort.
So I know exactly where they are. You post for a month, you get crickets, it stops being fun, and you start thinking you're talking to nobody and doing all this work for nothing. That's when most people quit, and I'm telling you, that's the reality for almost everyone at this stage.
I say this all the time: about half of being successful in business is not quitting. Of course, there has to be strategy behind it too, which is why we do this work together. But the other half? It's simply refusing to quit.
Why the Crickets Phase Is Where Most People Quit
The early years are when the most businesses disappear. The U.S. Small Business Administration's Office of Advocacy reports that of new employer businesses opened between 1994 and 2022, an average of 67.7% survived at least two years, and only 49.2% were still open at year five.
Those numbers cover every kind of business, so they aren't a prediction for your coaching practice. What they show is that the early years of building a business can be challenging, and making it through those first few years takes consistency, strategy, and a willingness to keep going.
When coaches close in that stretch, it's usually because posting into silence is demoralizing and nobody told them the silence was normal.
Count the Wins That Aren't Clients Yet
When you don't have a paying client yet, it's so easy to decide your business isn't moving. But think about everything that might be happening behind the scenes: new followers, more link clicks, a growing email list, and conversations with potential clients or collaborators.
One coach in our cohort works with picky eaters, and in the last few weeks she booked parent workshops with several daycares. A director called her and said they hadn't done parent training in a long time, and that parents across a few of their centers were excited about it. She already has her outline and handouts ready.
The same coach had a podcast interview get postponed the day it was supposed to happen. She'd listened to the host's episode on picky eating and written pages of notes and questions, so she's ready whenever it gets rescheduled. A postponement still counts as a door that opened.
Here's what those early signals tend to lead to:
| Early signal | What it tells you | What it can lead to |
|---|---|---|
| New followers | Your message is reaching the right people | A warmer audience for your next offer |
| Link clicks | People want more than the post | Email signups and lead magnet downloads |
| Email list growth | Someone gave you permission to stay in touch | Nurture emails that turn into discovery calls |
| A booked workshop or talk | Organizations see value in your expertise | Referrals and client inquiries from attendees |
| A podcast or collaboration invite | Other people trust you with their audience | Visibility you didn't have to build alone |
Your business is moving in a dozen ways before the first client shows up, and you only see them if you're looking.
The Boiling Water Problem
That same coach told us she thinks about one analogy every single day. If you're staring at a pot of water waiting for it to boil and you turn the burner off because it isn't doing anything, you might have been at 211 degrees, one degree away from boiling. You were right there.
Habit research tells the same story. In a study of 96 adults building a new daily habit, Lally and colleagues (2010) estimated it took a median of 66 days for a behavior to feel close to automatic, with individual estimates ranging from 18 to 254 days. Missing one day didn't materially affect the process.
Building a consistent posting routine takes repetition too, and the longer you stick with it, the more opportunities you have to learn what resonates with your audience. A Buffer analysis of more than 100,000 users found the most consistent posters got 450% more engagement per post than people who posted in four or fewer weeks out of 26. Buffer's 2026 creator growth playbook adds that even moderately consistent posters, active in 5 to 19 of those weeks, saw around 340% more engagement per post than sporadic posters. The schedule that works is the one you'll keep.
Consistency Looks Like Baby Steps
Think about how far you've come in the last month. The coaches in our cohort are more locked in and more focused than they were four weeks ago, and they'll be more focused and have more clarity a month from now.
The steps that get you there are small. You post the same idea in a carousel and a reel and see which one people gravitate toward. You write one nurture email. You reach out to one more potential collaborator, introduce yourself, and start building a relationship. None of it feels like progress on the day, and all of it adds up.
When to Adjust and When to Keep Going
Staying consistent leaves plenty of room for change. You can adjust the wording, the format or the offer and keep showing up while you do it.
Our picky eating coach noticed something odd with her workshops. More than one daycare started inviting their staff to join the parent session for free. She wondered whether her original pitch planted that idea, and she's going to adjust how she phrases it next time. She tweaked her message and kept booking, which is exactly the move.
Keep going when you're seeing the early signals in the table above, even if they're small. If you're consistently showing up but aren't seeing progress, look at your data and make small adjustments along the way. You don't have to abandon your strategy, but you also don't have to wait 20 weeks to figure out what's not working. Talk to someone you trust before you decide to stop altogether, because that's when you're most likely to be at 211 degrees.
Getting Started This Week
- Pick a rhythm you can keep. Choose the number of posts per week you can sustain for 20 weeks, even if it's two.
- Start a win list. Write down every new follower milestone, click, signup, reply and booked conversation.
- Reach out to one person. Tell someone what you do, your offer and your service, every week.
- Review on a schedule. Look at your signals once a month instead of after every post.
Keep Going With People Beside You
The crickets phase is so much easier when you have people reminding you that you might be at 211 degrees. That's exactly why we created Beyond Billable Hours. Through weekly calls, actionable homework, and a community of coaches who understand what you're building, you don't have to figure everything out alone. We're here to celebrate the small wins, help you adjust when something isn't working, and remind you why you started in the first place.
Chat soon! ✨ Sarah

Sarah Burby
Founder of Mind Body Behavior and Clinicians for MORE
More from the Journal

You're Not Weak. You're Burned Out. There's a Difference.
BCBA burnout is not a personal failure. It's what happens when people who genuinely care about helping others get trapped in systems built around bill...

BCBA Career Change: You're Not Starting Over, You're Adding On
BCBAs change careers every day, and most of them are not starting from scratch. They are taking years of behavior science training, clinical observati...
