Imposter Feelings When BCBAs Start Something New: How to Move Forward Without Permission

You've worked so hard to get your credential. You passed the exam. You have years of clinical experience. So why, when you start something new, does this voice in your head whisper that you have no idea what you're doing and someone is going to figure you out?
That feeling is imposter phenomenon, and I'm going to tell you something that changed everything for me: it doesn't go away when you achieve the next thing. It doesn't go away when you get board approval. It doesn't go away when you launch your program and fill all the spots. The shift happens when you stop trying to make it disappear and instead learn how to relate to it differently.
I spent years thinking that once I got my BCBA, once I started MBB, once we got NBHWC approval, I would finally feel like I belonged. I thought the imposter feelings were a sign that I wasn't ready, that I should wait, that I needed to be more prepared. What I learned instead is that the most important accomplishments in my life have come with those feelings intact, not after I've eliminated them.
"Imposter feelings don't go away when you achieve the next thing. The shift happens when you stop trying to make them disappear and learn how to relate to them differently."
What Imposter Phenomenon Actually Is (And Why The Name Matters)
Imposter phenomenon was first identified in 1978 by psychologist Pauline Rose Clance and Suzanne Imes in their landmark research on high-achieving women. They described it as a psychological experience where a person suffers from feelings of intellectual or professional fraudulence despite strong evidence to the contrary.
Here's what I want you to notice: they called it phenomenon, not syndrome. That distinction matters. A syndrome sounds like something is wrong with you. A phenomenon is something that happens, something universal, something almost everyone experiences at some point.
The truth is, imposter phenomenon is incredibly common among high-achieving people, and BCBAs fit that profile exactly. You worked hard enough to earn a credential that less than 3% of therapists hold. You stayed in a field where burnout rates are high because you care deeply about the work. You're the kind of person who shows up, puts in the effort, and holds yourself to high standards. Of course you feel this way when you're doing something new, something that pushes you outside of what you've already proven you can do.
What happens for a lot of us is we internalize a story that goes something like this: "I'm only good at what I've already done. I might have gotten lucky with what I accomplished so far. If I step into something new, people are going to see that I don't actually know what I'm doing."
Why Imposter Feelings Show Up When You're Starting Something New
When you're thinking about pivoting careers as a BCBA, when you're considering health coaching or private practice or consulting or anything outside of the traditional autism clinic setting, your brain starts doing something very specific. It starts building what behavioral scientists call relational frames.
I know that sounds clinical, but stay with me because this is where everything clicks into place.
A relational frame is basically a learned pattern of connecting ideas together. Your brain does this automatically. Right now, your brain probably has a very strong connection between "BCBA" and a few specific things: writing behavior plans, conducting FBAs, working with kids, working in a clinic setting, supervision, certification. These are all linked together in your mind because that's what you've spent years doing.
But when you start something new, let's say health coaching, your brain doesn't automatically create a new frame that says "BCBA who does health coaching." Instead, it tries to fit this new thing into your existing network. And here's what happens: new thing equals unknown equals risky equals "you probably can't do this." Your brain is literally pattern-matching new territory against everything you've already succeeded at, and it's finding gaps.
The other piece is how you tie your identity to achievement. For most high-achieving people, and definitely for most BCBAs I know, your sense of self-worth got connected to competence a long time ago. Maybe in school, where you were the smart one. Maybe from parents who praised effort and achievement. Maybe from the field itself, where you had to be exceptional just to get certified. So when you step into something where you're not yet the expert, where you're learning, where you're not immediately excellent, your identity feels threatened.
That's not a character flaw. That's a learning history.
The Two Loops That Keep You Stuck
When imposter feelings show up, you typically respond in one of two ways, and both of them create problems.
Loop 1: The Achievement Trap
You feel like a fraud, so you work harder. You achieve the next thing. You get short-term relief, and for a moment, you believe you're not an imposter. But then the feelings come back, because achievement doesn't actually change how you relate to yourself. So you pursue the next accomplishment. And the next one. And the next one. You're running a hamster wheel, getting more and more exhausted, never actually reaching the place where you finally feel like you belong.
I did this for years. When I started MBB, I felt completely overwhelmed. So I worked more. I built more. I achieved more. And every time I hit a milestone, I thought "now I'll feel okay." When we got our first 30 students, I thought that would be it. When we hit 100 members in Clinicians Doing More, surely then. When I made my first seven figures, when we got board approval, when we're about to host our second annual retreat and our first ACT for Health and Wellness Conference, I kept waiting for that feeling of "I belong here" to finally stick.
It didn't work like that.
Loop 2: The Avoidance Trap
You feel like a fraud, so you don't do the thing. You tell yourself you're not ready yet. You'll launch when you've learned more. You'll put yourself out there when you feel more confident. This gives you short-term relief too, you don't have to risk failure or judgment. But it also keeps you stuck, because you never build the evidence that you actually can do this.
Both loops have something in common: they're about running from the feeling of being an imposter rather than learning how to move forward while having that feeling.
What Actually Changed For Me: The Mindset Shift
Two years ago, I was putting together a CEU course on burnout. I'd been studying burnout for years. I felt ready. I worked on this course for six months, had my business mentor help me lay it out, and then two nights before launch, I messaged her at 11 PM asking her to review it one more time.
She said no.
And she told me why: "If I looked it over one more time, I'd be reinforcing your need for external validation before you put something out there. You're looking for me to tell you it's good enough, but the truth is, the course is ready. You just don't feel ready. Those are two different things."
I was furious in that moment. And then I was grateful.
Because here's what I realized: I was waiting for a feeling to change before I took action. I was waiting to feel confident before I launched. I was waiting to feel like an expert before I called myself one. And that meant I was giving my imposter feelings the power to decide what I did and didn't do.
The shift for me wasn't learning to eliminate the imposter feelings. It was learning to notice them, acknowledge them, and then ask myself one question: "What do I want in this moment in the service of my values?"
Not "How do I make this feeling go away?" but "What matters to me here, and am I willing to do it while feeling scared?"
When I got board approval for the NBHWC program, I had that fight-or-flight response again. I felt like a fraud all over again. But this time, instead of waiting until the feeling passed, instead of over-preparing to prove myself, I recognized it as a moment of possibility. I could either freeze and protect myself, or I could move forward. I chose to move forward. I marketed the program. I filled all the spots. And the program launched successfully.
The imposter feelings didn't get smaller. I just got better at not letting them be the boss of my decisions.
How to Relate to Imposter Feelings Differently
There's a metaphor I use all the time with my health coaching clients and with the supervisors I work with. Think about a beach ball in a pool.
Imagine all your imposter syndrome thoughts, all your self-doubt, all your "you're not good enough" messages are inside that beach ball. Now imagine trying to push that ball underwater. You can do it. You can hold it there. But you have to keep pushing. Your muscles get tight. You get exhausted. And the moment you get tired, the moment you loosen your grip, that ball is going to shoot up out of the water and smack you in the face harder than it would have if you'd just let it float.
That's what happens when we fight our imposter feelings. We exhaust ourselves trying to push them away, and they always come back stronger.
What if instead, we just let the beach ball float?
The imposter feelings are still there. They're still in the pool. But you're not using all your energy trying to suppress them. You can actually move around. You can swim. You can do the things you came to the pool to do.
Here's another way to think about it: take an index card and write down all your imposter syndrome thoughts. "I'm going to mess this up." "I don't actually know what I'm doing." "Someone's going to figure out I'm a fraud." Write them all down. Now imagine holding that card right in front of your face, so close you can't see anything else.
You can't present. You can't teach. You can't launch your program. All you can see is the card.
But what if you just put the card in your back pocket? You're still carrying those thoughts. They're still with you. But now you can see the slides. You can see the faces of the people you're helping. You can do the work that matters to you. The thoughts don't go away, but they're not running the show anymore.
This is what behavioral scientists call psychological flexibility, a core concept in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy. It's not about eliminating negative thoughts. It's about creating enough space between you and those thoughts that you can choose your behavior based on your values, not based on how you feel.
The Permission You Don't Need
Here's the thing I wish I'd known much earlier: you don't need permission to pivot.
You don't need your employer's approval. My former employer told me health coaching would never make money. I was too busy building my seven-figure business to argue with them.
You don't need to feel more confident first. Confidence doesn't come before action, it comes after you've done the thing and seen that you survived it.
You don't need to know everything. You don't need to be the expert. You just need to be clear about who you can help and willing to figure out the rest as you go.
The only permission you need is the permission you give yourself.
When I started thinking about becoming a health coach as a BCBA, I had to get really clear on something: who am I trying to help here? Not "who do I think I should help" or "who does the field say I should help," but who do I actually care about?
The answer was BCBAs like me. Burnt out. Questioning if this was it for their career. Carrying guilt about wanting something different. Trying to figure out if they could pivot without blowing up everything they'd worked for.
That clarity changed everything. Because suddenly, I wasn't trying to build a program for some abstract ideal client. I was building it for people I knew intimately. People I'd been. The expertise I needed wasn't "be the world's best health coach." It was "understand what it feels like to be a BCBA who wants more."
What Comes After the Pivot
I want to be really honest about something: this isn't a story where I overcome imposter feelings and then live happily ever after without them.
I still have them. When we were getting ready to host our first ACT for Health and Wellness Conference in August, I had that moment again. "What if nobody comes? What if this doesn't work? What if people think I'm trying too hard or overstepping?"
But here's what's different: I recognize it. I notice it. And I don't let it stop me.
I've built a business helping over 100 people in my Clinicians Doing More community. I've filled six cohorts of the health coaching program with a seventh launching soon. I've built an email list of over 10,000 people who trust me to show up and share what I know. I've done all of that while feeling like an imposter some of the time.
And you know what that tells me? That the imposter feelings aren't the problem. The problem is when we let them make our decisions for us.
Ready to move forward without permission?
The pivot you're thinking about is exactly where you need to go. If you're ready to build something new alongside BCBAs who get it, explore our health coaching certification.
EXPLORE THE CERTIFICATIONWhere to Start Right Now
If you're sitting with imposter feelings about something you want to do, something that scares you a little bit, here's what I want you to do:
-
Name the thought, don't fight it. What's the specific thought that comes up? "I don't know enough." "I'm going to embarrass myself." "I'm not qualified for this." Write it down. Don't try to argue with it or convince yourself it's not true. Just notice it.
-
Get clear on who you're trying to help. Not who you think you should help. Who do you actually care about? What problem do you actually understand because you've lived it? For me, it's burnt-out BCBAs figuring out their next move. For you, it might be something different. But get specific.
-
Create a values-based goal. Instead of an outcome goal ("I need to launch a program" or "I need to make six figures"), create a values-based goal. "I want to help BCBAs like me find freedom and fulfillment" or "I want to build a practice that's aligned with my values." Now every small action toward that goal counts as success, regardless of the outcome.
-
Notice the choice point. When the imposter feelings show up, when you feel scared, you have a choice point. You can protect yourself by staying small, or you can move forward in the service of what matters to you. Neither choice is wrong. But notice that you have a choice.
You've worked too hard and come too far to let imposter feelings make your decisions for you. The pivot you're thinking about, the idea that keeps you up at night, the thing that scares you a little bit, that's probably exactly where you need to go.
And the imposter feelings? They can come along for the ride.
Chat soon! ✨
Sarah
FAQ: Imposter Feelings When BCBAs Start Something New
If I'm experiencing imposter feelings, does that mean I'm not actually ready to make this pivot?
No. Imposter feelings are not a sign that you're not ready. They're a sign that you're doing something that matters to you, something that challenges you. The fact that you feel scared doesn't mean you should wait. It means you're on the edge of growth.
Will the imposter feelings ever go away completely?
Probably not, and that's okay. They might get quieter. You might notice them less often. But the goal isn't to eliminate them. The goal is to stop letting them be in charge of your decisions. You can have imposter feelings and still launch that program, still make that pivot, still build something you're proud of.
What's the difference between imposter syndrome and just not knowing enough about a new field?
If you genuinely don't have the skills or knowledge you need, that's a different problem, you get training. But imposter feelings happen even when you have the skills. You feel like a fraud despite evidence to the contrary. You discount your accomplishments. You attribute success to luck rather than ability. That's imposter phenomenon, and it's not about needing more training.
How do I know if I'm in the achievement loop or the avoidance loop?
The achievement loop feels like constantly reaching for the next accomplishment, thinking "once I do this, I'll feel okay." The avoidance loop feels like waiting until you're ready, until you feel more confident, until conditions are perfect. Both end up keeping you stuck. The way out is moving forward regardless of how you feel.
What if I pivot and then realize I made a mistake?
Then you've learned something valuable, and you can adjust. But the regret of not trying is worse than the risk of trying and discovering it wasn't for you. I've built multiple things in my career, and I'm not afraid of failure because I'm more afraid of looking back in 20 years wondering "what if."
Can a BCBA really make a successful pivot without starting from scratch?
Yes. Your BCBA credential, your clinical experience, your understanding of behavior, these are assets in almost any direction you pivot. Health coaching, private practice, consulting, speaking, writing, all of these benefit from the expertise you already have. You're not starting from zero.

Sarah Burby
Founder of Mind Body Behavior and Clinicians for MORE
More from the Journal

You're Not Weak. You're Burned Out. There's a Difference.
BCBA burnout is not a personal failure. It's what happens when people who genuinely care about helping others get trapped in systems built around bill...

BCBA Career Change: You're Not Starting Over, You're Adding On
BCBAs change careers every day, and most of them are not starting from scratch. They are taking years of behavior science training, clinical observati...
