What BCBAs Get Wrong About Client Motivation (and What to Do Instead)

BCBAs are trained to identify what's wrong and fix it as efficiently as possible. That precision is exactly what makes them excellent behavior analysts, and it's also the instinct that most gets in the way of effective health coaching. The shift from expert problem-solver to curious partner is the single biggest adjustment BCBAs have to make, and once they make it, everything about how they work with clients changes.
Here's something nobody tells you when you're going through a behavior analysis program: being really good at your job might be the hardest thing to leave at the door when you sit down with a coaching client.
And I get it, because I've been there. You're trained to assess, hypothesize, intervene, and measure. You walk into a session, you listen for about three minutes, and your brain is already organizing the problem and generating solutions. You can see exactly what this person needs to do. You want to help.
That instinct is not wrong. It's actually one of the things that makes BCBAs so effective. But in a coaching session, leading with that expert hat is the fastest way to lose the person sitting across from you, and most BCBAs don't realize they're doing it until they've already done it.
The Instinct BCBAs Have to Notice First
There is a concept in motivational interviewing called the righting reflex, and if you're a BCBA, you have it in full force. The righting reflex is that automatic pull toward correcting what's wrong, offering solutions, sharing what you know. It comes from genuinely caring about the outcome. The problem is that when the righting reflex takes over in a coaching conversation, you stop listening for what the client actually needs and start listening for confirmation of what you've already decided they need.
It sounds like: "Have you thought about trying X?" "What if you just did Y?" "I know something that works really well for this."
Every one of those things might be true. And every one of them pulls the client out of the driver's seat and puts you in it instead.
One of the coaches we train at Mind Body Behavior described this perfectly. She said that when a client told her "you tell me" during a session, meaning tell me what my next goal should be, she panicked. Her instinct was to just answer, because she knew what would probably work. But the whole point of coaching is that it's not about what you think will work. It's about what the client is ready to move toward, and those two things are often very different.
The Difference Between Extrinsic and Intrinsic Motivation (and Why BCBAs Default to the Wrong One)
BCBAs understand reinforcement better than almost any other profession. We know how to build systems that work. External rewards, token economies, behavior contracts, we've used all of them, and we've seen them produce real behavior change. So when we move into health coaching, it's natural to reach for those same tools.
But here's the thing about extrinsic motivation in coaching: it can get someone started, but it almost never gets them sustained. And sustainable change is the entire job.
A client who is eating better because they have a reunion coming up will stop eating better after the reunion. A client who is exercising because they bought a gym membership will stop exercising when the guilt about the sunk cost wears off. External motivation is useful as a bridge, and sometimes you do need to start there, but the goal is always to find the internal reason that makes the behavior worth maintaining when nobody's watching and no reward is waiting.
"The moment a client names what they actually want, not what they think they should want, you have something real to coach toward."
A client might come in saying they want to lose weight. Fine. But when you ask enough questions and get curious enough, you often find out that what they actually want is to have more energy when they're playing with their kids, or to stop feeling like they're disappearing inside their own body, or to get off a medication that's been making them feel like a stranger to themselves. Those are intrinsic motivations. Those are the ones that survive contact with real life.
What Happens When You Stop Trying to Be Interesting and Start Being Interested
One of the most common traps new coaches fall into, and this is especially true for BCBAs, is trying to be impressive in the session. You want to ask the smart question. You want to say the thing that makes the client feel like they're getting their money's worth. You want to demonstrate your knowledge.
The irony is that the more you try to be interesting, the less useful you are.
The coaches who get the best results are the ones who become genuinely, almost annoyingly, curious about the person in front of them. They ask questions that have no agenda attached. They follow threads that don't seem to go anywhere and discover that they go somewhere the client has never been asked about before. They notice things, not to fix them, but just to name them: "It sounds like having people around you matters a lot."
That kind of noticing, the kind that has no prescription behind it, is what makes clients feel seen. And clients who feel seen will go further, try harder, and tell you more of the truth than clients who feel like they're being assessed.
BCBAs are actually wired for this kind of observation. We've spent careers watching people closely. The shift is not in the observation, it's in what we do with what we notice. In ABA, we observe and then we intervene. In coaching, we observe and then we get curious.
The question "how do you know that's true?" is one of the most powerful things you can say when a client makes a definitive statement about themselves. "I just can't stick with anything." Really? How do you know that? And suddenly the story they've been telling themselves has a crack in it, and they're the ones who found it.
Why Telling Clients What to Do Doesn't Work (Even When You're Right)
There is a lot of health advice in the world. Doctors, trainers, nutritionists, wellness influencers, everyone is telling people what they should do. And yet behavior change remains one of the hardest things for human beings to sustain. The information is not the problem. The motivation to apply the information, consistently, without external pressure, is the problem.
This is where BCBAs and health coaching are a natural match, and it's also where BCBAs have to make the biggest mindset shift. The Acceptance and Commitment Therapy framework that many BCBAs already know points toward this: people don't sustain behavior change because they were told to. They sustain it because it's connected to something they actually value.
A client who sets a goal because their coach suggested it has the coach's motivation, not their own. A client who sets a goal because a coaching conversation helped them see what they actually care about has something that belongs to them. That difference is everything when real life gets in the way, which it will.
The practical application: stop solving for the stated problem. Get curious about what's underneath it. A client who says "I want to work out more" might actually be craving a sense of accomplishment. A client who says "I want to eat better" might actually be trying to get back something they lost, energy, confidence, a feeling of being in their own body. A client who says "I just want to feel like myself again" might not need a single thing changed about their diet or exercise and might need a completely different kind of conversation.
You don't know until you ask. And you can only ask if you're willing to not know first.
Ready to expand your work beyond ASD without abandoning your BCBA skillset?
Take the MBB 360 Assessment and discover a structured way to assess wellness, values, barriers, and next steps.
TAKE THE ASSESSMENTHow to Actually Use Your BCBA Skills in a Coaching Session
Here's the good news: you don't leave your BCBA training at the door. You just use it differently.
- Observation becomes your sharpest tool. You've spent years watching for the thing people aren't saying directly. In coaching, that skill is the whole job. What is the client not saying? What are they circling around? Where do they get quieter, or more animated, or more careful with their words? Your trained eye for behavior is a genuine advantage.
- Values work is behavior analysis. When we help a client identify their values and connect their daily choices back to those values, we are doing committed action work, exactly as you'd recognize it from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy. You already have the conceptual framework. You just have to apply it outside the clinical context.
- Reinforcement still matters, you just use it differently. Celebrating small wins is a coaching skill. Helping a client notice what's working and build on it rather than always focusing on the gap is a reinforcement principle. The difference is that in coaching, you're not the one delivering the reinforcer. You're helping the client learn to notice and name their own progress, so the reinforcement becomes self-sustaining.
- Your tolerance for measurement is a superpower. BCBAs are comfortable with data in a way most coaches are not. Helping clients track how they actually feel, not just what they did, and reviewing that data together across sessions builds a kind of self-awareness that most people have never had access to before.
Over 150 BCBAs and RBTs have now come through the health coaching program at Mind Body Behavior, and what we see consistently is that the skills transfer faster than anyone expects. The mindset shift takes more time, but once it clicks, it tends to click completely.
Nicole, BCBA, described her shift this way:
"I wasn't feeling like I constantly had to have all the answers. I was there as a partner to help them discover what they thought was the best solution."
That's the whole thing, right there.
Where to Start If You're a BCBA Who Wants to Coach
The fastest way to start thinking like a coach is to practice not having the answer.
In your next conversation with a colleague, a friend, a family member who comes to you with a problem, try this: ask three questions before you say anything prescriptive. Just three. Get curious about what they actually want, not what they say they want. Ask how they know the thing they're assuming is true. Ask what would feel different if that changed.
You'll be surprised how much changes when you stop solving and start listening.
For BCBAs who want to build this into a real skill set, a certification matters. The NBHWC-approved health coaching program at Mind Body Behavior was built for exactly this: behavior analysts who want to add health coaching in a way that's rigorous, evidence-based, and counts toward the 40 CEUs you need for BCBA recertification anyway.
FAQ: BCBA Client Motivation and Health Coaching
What is motivational interviewing and why does it matter for BCBAs?
Motivational interviewing is an evidence-based approach to supporting behavior change that focuses on drawing out the client's own motivation rather than imposing the coach's agenda. BCBAs already use MI principles in ABA contexts but often need to practice applying them in a client-led coaching framework where the client, not the clinician, sets the direction.
What is the righting reflex and how does it affect coaching?
The righting reflex is the automatic pull toward correcting what's wrong and offering solutions. BCBAs tend to have a strong righting reflex because of their training in problem identification and intervention. In coaching, this instinct can undermine the session by shifting the client out of the driver's seat before they have a chance to find their own motivation.
What is the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in health coaching?
Extrinsic motivation comes from external factors like rewards, social pressure, or upcoming events. Intrinsic motivation comes from internal values and a genuine sense of why something matters. Health coaching is most effective when it helps clients connect behavior change to intrinsic motivation, because intrinsic motivation sustains behavior when external conditions change.
How can a BCBA use their existing skills in health coaching?
BCBAs bring strong observation skills, values-based frameworks like ACT, behavior measurement literacy, and a deep understanding of behavior change science. In coaching these translate into the ability to notice what clients aren't saying, connect daily choices back to values, help clients track their own progress, and support sustainable behavior change. The main adjustment is shifting from prescribing solutions to drawing them out through curiosity.
Why do BCBAs have to unlearn the expert role in coaching?
In ABA, the behavior analyst is often the expert who assesses, designs, and drives the intervention. In health coaching, the client is the expert in their own life and the coach's job is to help them access that expertise. BCBAs who lead with clinical authority in coaching sessions often find clients become dependent or disengaged rather than self-directed.
How does health coaching differ from behavior analytic intervention?
Health coaching is client-led, present and future-focused, and built on eliciting the client's own motivation rather than delivering an expert-designed intervention. ABA is clinician-directed and involves structured assessment and intervention design. The two approaches are complementary, and BCBAs who understand both can move between them fluidly depending on the context and the client's needs.

Sarah Burby
Founder of Mind Body Behavior and Clinicians for MORE
More from the Journal

You're Not Weak. You're Burned Out. There's a Difference.
BCBA burnout is not a personal failure. It's what happens when people who genuinely care about helping others get trapped in systems built around bill...

BCBA Career Change: You're Not Starting Over, You're Adding On
BCBAs change careers every day, and most of them are not starting from scratch. They are taking years of behavior science training, clinical observati...
